Thursday, March 15, 2007

PaleoClimate Change, Fossil Fuel Combustion and Human Effects on Climate

PaleoClimate Change, Fossil Fuel Combustion and Human Effects on Climate
The history of earth’s climate changes leads to three conclusions 1) large changes in climate have occurred; from snowball earth to no ice on earth, 2) changes in CO2 (and in oxygen) concentration in the atmosphere have occurred and may be correllated with climate changes, 3) the invention of farming 10,000 years ago is thought by some to have had significant climate impacts. Therefore man does not have the choice of not affecting earth’s climate, his choice is on how he will affect it. It is not a question of minimizing the impacts, the decision is on what impacts are acceptable or desired.

Paleoclimate

Approximately 600 million years ago there were glaciers within 20 degrees of the equator i.e. they were as close to the equator as Hawaii or Mexico City. This period of time was called iceball earth. At that time the continents were collected in one land mass and there were very large mountains near the equator. The CO2 in the atmosphere was very low. On the other hand during much of earth’s history (80%) there have been no glaciers on earth. For example during the entire reign of the dinosaurs 250 million years ago to 65 million years ago there were no glaciers anyplace on earth. During this period of time the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere was high compared to the CO2 concentration now. Glaciers started forming in Antartica about 35 million years ago and in the north, the Arctic, only 6 or 7 million years ago. So the current climate of earth is not typical, in fact no climate could be called typical. The earth’s climate changes with time.

Correlation of Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide concentration and Glaciation
The chart (from Wikipedia by Robert H. Rohde) below shows the carbon dioxide levels versus time for the last 500 million years. Note that there are periods where the CO2 level is as much as 5000 ppm or 25 times current levels. The periods of low CO2, about 300 million years ago and the last 10 million years or so are periods of glaciation. There is considerable additional evidence showing a correlation between CO2 and glaciers and that the CO2 has varied over a wide range in earth’s history.

Carbon Dioxide and Fossil Fuel Combustion
Current atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration is about 360 ppm and represents 750 gigatons of CO2 in the atmosphere. The amount of fossil fuels which are available for combustion are given the following table(Jeff Siirola, private communication)
Gigatons of carbon
Oil including shale oil and tar sands 595
Natural gas 75
Coal 925
Total fossil fuels at a high price 2500
Methane hydrates 1000-10,000

So combusting all the fossil fuels (2500 gigatons) will raise the CO2 in the atmosphere, if it all remained in the atmosphere, to about 1600 ppm. If we only burnt the readily available oil, natural gas and coal the atmospheric CO2 concentration would be about 1100 ppm. Note that this range of CO2 is well within the range of atmospheric CO2 concentration shown in the last 500 million years.

Effect of Farming on Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Concentration
Ruddiman describes his research on the effect of farming and other activities 10,000 years ago on CO2 concentrations. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plows,_Plagues_and_Petroleum)
He believes that the CO2 and methane concentration as early as 10,000 years ago were higher than expected and that this prevented a new ice age about 5,000 year ago. In addition he ascribes historic impacts on the human population and activities, like the Black Plague, to climate changes like the Little Ice Age. If this is correct then human activities have been affecting CO2 and other greenhouse gases and climate for 10,000 years and will continue to affect the climate. It is not reasonable to eliminate the climate effects of farming. Note that many biofuel projects, which are proposed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, will increase the amount of farming. Although they will not increase the CO2 emissions as much as burning fossil fuels, they will increase the emissions measurably.

Fossil Fuel Consumption
We can calculate how long it would take to consume the presumed 2500 gigatons of fossil fuels. Assume current consumption of fossil fuels is 7 gigatons of carbon per year and postulate a 2% growth in fossil fuel consumption. In about 60 years we will consume 775 gigatons of carbon i.e. we will double the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere. After about 100 years we will have consumed about 2200 gigatons of carbon. This of course assumes that all fossil fuels are equivalent. This calculation is done to give an approximate feeling for the time which fossil fuels might last in abundance. There will still be small, high cost sources of fossil fuels for a long time.

Conclusions
No climate in earth’s history is “normal”, it changes over geologic time.
No atmosphere composition is “normal”, it changes over geologic time, both oxygen and carbon dioxide.
Man’s actions are changing the atmosphere composition, carbon dioxide.
The change in atmosphere composition, carbon dioxide, is likely to affect the climate. The CO2 concentration and climate do appear to be correlated in earth’s history.
It is unrealistic to expect that man can/will control his activities so as to not affect greenhouse gases and therefore the climate.

Considering the above it seems prudent to think realistically about what climate is desireable and achieveable on earth. Certainly burning fuels with the highest possible efficiency is desireable but it seems likely that all fossil fuels will be consumed within 100 years or so. At that time the atmospheric CO2 concentration will be about 1000-2000 ppm. From paleoclimate evidence we'd expect an earth with no glaciers but well within acceptable climates at most places on earth. The earth's been there before. However the sea level would be about 100 meters above today's level. This would inundate many coastal areas as illustrated in Al Gore's film "An Inconvenient Truth".